Balance billing is when a doctor or clinic charges a patient for the unpaid gap between the amount the provider asks for and what the patient’s health plan pays. This can show up after treatment from an out-of-network clinician or a facility. Whereas, the surprise billing is a narrower kind of this problem. It happens when the patient did not have a real chance to choose an in-network option. Common examples are an emergency, or care from an out-of-network specialist while the patient is inside an in-network hospital. Texas handles both issues with two state bills: Senate Bill 1264 and Senate Bill 2476. These rules are used with the federal No Surprises Act, often called the NSA, to tell which protections apply and which plans are covered.
The Difference Between “Balance Billing” and “Surprise Billing”?
The two terms are related, but they are not the same. Balance billing can occur in more cases. Surprise billing only applies when the patient lacked a meaningful choice.
Balance Billing:
Balance billing means an out-of-network provider bills the patient for the extra amount. This is the difference between what the provider charges and what the health plan pays.
Surprise billing:
Surprise billing is a kind of balance bill. It can happen during emergency care. It can also happen when an out-of-network provider works in a facility that is in-network. Another example is an out-of-network ambulance.IThe situations in which the patient could not realistically choose an in-network provider.
The Texas law and federal NSA do not address all cases of balance medical billing, but only surprise billing. With signed, informed consent, a patient who voluntarily selects an out-of-network provider is not covered by these protections.
Texas Senate Bill 1264: Core State Protections
It is now law in Texas as Senate Bill 1264 and took effect on January 1, 2020. It shields enrolled individuals in a state regulated health plan, such as fully insured health plans regulated by the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), from getting surprise medical bills. A patient’s share of the cost of care under a health plan shall not exceed the usual and customary copayment, coinsurance or deductible for services rendered by an out-of-network provider, except as provided in SB 1264.
What SB 1264 Covers
- Emergency care, at any facility, regardless of network status
- Out-of-network facility-based providers treating a patient at an in-network hospital or surgical center (radiologists, anesthesiologists, pathologists, neonatologists, and assistant surgeons are common examples)
- Lab and diagnostic imaging services connected to an in-network service
What SB 1264 Does Not Cover
- Self-funded, ERISA-regulated employer health plans. These plans fall under federal jurisdiction, not Texas state insurance law, and make up the majority of employer-sponsored coverage in Texas.
- Non-emergency care a patient chooses in writing to receive from an out-of-network provider, after that provider discloses in advance that the service is out-of-network and provides a cost estimate.
Dispute Resolution Under SB 1264
SB 1264 keeps the patient out of the payment dispute entirely. Health plans and providers resolve disagreements over payment through two separate tracks managed by TDI, depending on the type of provider involved.
| Dispute Type | Applies To | Process |
|---|---|---|
| Mediation | Out-of-network facilities | No filing deadline under the law; requests submitted through TDI’s portal |
| Arbitration | Individual out-of-network providers (physicians, etc.) | Each side submits a proposed payment amount and the arbitrator picks one |
Senate Bill 2476: Ground Ambulance and EMS Coverage
One thing was missing from SB 1264 and that was the ground ambulance transport. The original Texas law and the federal NSA didn’t deal with ground EMS because ambulance billing works differently than billing for a hospital or a physician. About a quarter of ground ambulance trips in the country result in an unexpected bill and almost 60% of ambulance rides are outside of network. To fill that gap, Senate Bill (SB) 2476 was passed by Senator Judith Zaffirini and adopted in 2023, and takes effect for all transports since January 1, 2024.
SB 2476 prohibits ground ambulance providers, including municipal EMS agencies, from balance billing patients for out-of-network transport. Instead, health plans must reimburse the ground EMS provider directly.

Reimbursement Rates Under SB 2476
- Where a local governmental entity has set a rate for ground ambulance coverage, health plans must pay that rate.
- Where no local rate exists, health plans pay the lesser of the billed charge or 325% of the Medicare allowable rate.
- The law covers ground ambulance and EMS transport only. Air ambulance services are addressed separately under the federal NSA, not SB 2476.
Texas ground ambulance protections were originally set to sunset in September 2025 and have since been extended to September 1, 2027.
Texas Law Review of Alignment with the Federal No Surprises Act (NSA)
Coverage type SB 1264 is not covered by the federal No Surprises Act, which went into effect January 1, 2022, and would cover self-funded, ERISA-regulated employer plans nationwide. This includes emergency care, out-of-network post-stabilization care, non-emergency care at an out-of-network provider that is in an in-network facility, and air ambulance transportation. It does not include ground ambulance transport, which is the reason why SB 2476 is important at the state level.
Texas’s law is a specified state law recognized by federal law. This means that SB 1264 and SB 2476 do not pre-empt the NSA and do still apply to state regulated, fully insured plans. Self-funded ERISA plans continue to be subject to the federal NSA rules. House Bill 1592, passed by the Texas legislature and effective September 1, 2023, permits a plan sponsor to choose to be subject to Texas state law (as opposed to federal NSA) for a particular plan year by filing the election with TDI.
| Plan or Service Type | Governing Law | Balance Billing Prohibited? |
|---|---|---|
| State-regulated fully insured plan, emergency or in-network facility with OON provider | Texas SB 1264 | Yes |
| Ground ambulance, state-regulated plan | Texas SB 2476 | Yes |
| Air ambulance, any applicable plan | Federal NSA | Yes |
| Self-funded ERISA plan (not opted into Texas law) | Federal NSA | Yes, under federal rules |
| Self-funded ERISA plan (opted into Texas law under HB 1592) | Texas SB 1264 / SB 2476 | Yes, under state rules |

What This Means for Texas Medical Billing
The first and more crucial step is to correctly identify the type of plan before billing. An ERISA plan that is self-funded can be treated as a state-regulated plan or vice versa, and this could lead to misapplying the right dispute resolution or failing to include the proper disclosure. If SB 1264 applies, or if SB 2476 applies, then health plans are required to provide an explanation of benefits that includes the prohibition of a balance bill and itemizes the patient’s copayment, coinsurance, and deductible. For any out-of-network claim, practices and billing teams involved in Texas medical billing must verify each plan’s type (whether state or self-funded), whether it is subject to SB 1264, 2476, or the federal NSA, and which dispute resolution path is most appropriate (mediation, arbitration, or the federal IDR process).
Getting this classification wrong is one of the common sources of compliance risk in Texas billing operations, since the correct process and the correct amount a patient can legally be billed depends entirely on it. Vigilant Medical Billing & Coding Services builds this plan-type verification into its claims workflow before a claim goes out, rather than resolving it after a denial or complaint.
Schedule a Free Billing Audit with Vigilant Medical Billing & Coding Services
Conclusion:
Protection against surprises in the bills now has three layers in Texas. SB 1264 applies to state regulated fully insured plans for emergency care and out-of-network providers at in-network facilities. SB 2476 fills the ground ambulance void left by SB 1264 and the federal NSA. The federal NSA provides coverage for self-funded ERISA plans and air ambulance on a national level, except for those plans that choose to comply with Texas law because of HB 1592. According to the plan type, the applicable law will be determined, and getting it correct on the first try can help prevent denied claims, compliance risks, and disputes that might otherwise require mediation, arbitration, or the federal IDR process.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between balance billing and surprise billing in Texas?
Balance billing occurs when a provider bills any gap between provider’s rate and the health plan’s payment. The term “surprise billing” is used to describe just those instances when a patient could not select an in-network provider, for example, emergencies, out-of-network specialists provided at in-network hospitals.
Does Texas Senate Bill 1264 apply to every health plan?
No. SB 1264 applies only to fully insured plans. Those plans must be overseen by the Texas Department of Insurance. Self-funded employer plans that are governed by ERISA are subject to the federal No Surprises Act rather than the state laws of Texas unless the plan sponsor chooses to opt in to Texas law under House Bill 1592.
Are ground ambulance rides covered under Texas balance billing law?
Yes, as of January 1, 2024, under Senate Bill 2476. There is no provision for municipal agencies and ground ambulance and EMS service providers to be able to bill out-of-network patients. Health plans must instead pay the local government rate where one exists, or the lesser of the billed charge or 325% of Medicare where it does not.
What happens if a patient’s health plan is self-funded through their employer?
Self-funded ERISA plans are generally governed by the federal No Surprises Act rather than Texas SB 1264 or SB 2476, unless the employer has elected to opt into Texas law under House Bill 1592. Confirming plan funding status is a required step before determining which balance billing protections and dispute resolution process apply.
How are billing disputes resolved between providers and health plans in Texas?
Under SB 1264, disputes involving out-of-network facilities go through mediation, and disputes involving individual out-of-network providers go through baseball-style arbitration, both managed through TDI’s dispute resolution portal. Disputes involving self-funded ERISA plans not opted into Texas law instead go through the federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process established under the No Surprises Act.


